All Research
By Topic
Data and Analytics
Fixed Income
Interview-based Studies
Vision Notes
A Spotlight in the Dark: An Inevitable Debate 
Author:  Miranda Mizen 
Date:   11/16/2012 
Price: US $ 3,000.00 

A Spotlight in the Dark: An Inevitable Debate

Executive Summary
It is clear from the hearings in Washington, SEC investigations, academic publications and water cooler conversations that at best, the US faces a severe image problem. In this research we continue our exploration of the issues and impact of market structure on the investor community and put the spotlight on one of the more contentious and inevitable debates around trading in the dark.

Currently, approximately 30% to 33% of all equity trading occurs off-exchange and is reported to one of the Trade Reporting Facilities. Dark trading occurs virtually indiscriminately across exchange-listed securities and some of the most liquid and highest capitalized securities have almost half their trading volume reported through the TRF. Buy-side traders with oversized orders to fill want sizeable fills, natural counterparties and the ability to avoid being seen, and the quality of the open markets makes the them willing partners in the dark. 

The use of dark and undisplayed orders also on the exchange order books essentially makes the difference between dark execution on- and off the exchanges primarily one of regulatory framework rather than a debate over dark versus lit. In the aggregate, the details of the many exchange order types and rules that govern the markets create a tangle of detail, and in the highly fragmented market, this overwhelming detail adds to the complexity.

Many market participants believe the equity markets are now too fragmented and too opaque, and dark pools contribute to this. As dark execution comes under the microscope as part of the broader market structure debate, we believe the rules surrounding off-exchange trading in US equities will change — it is only a matter of time.   But on- and off-exchange dark execution represents unique and valuable execution strategies, and there is danger in tarring all dark activity with the same brush. Any review must consider both environments. Any focus on dark trading needs to be grounded in data and measured against benchmarks of fairness and efficiency in the market to avoid being subject to speculation, polarized opinion and needle-moving regulation. 

The TABB Group Vision Note A Spotlight in the Dark: An Inevitable Debate puts the spotlight on one of the more contentious debates around trading in the dark and we inquire into dark execution on- and off-exchange and ask questions around the protected quote, criteria for off-exchange trading, and transparency. Trading outside the lit order books offers legitimate value and advantages but the industry lacks consensus about its cause and effect.  Given current trends, action seems inevitable, but to be effective, the dark debate must be part of the broader market structure debate that includes the quality and efficiency of the lit markets.


Related Reports 
More from This Author 
European Clearing and Settlement: Breaking Barriers-Building Alliances
Exchanges Add Dark Pools Downstream
Real-Time Risk: Managing Execution Risk in an Increasingly Electronic World
The NYSE is Heralding a New Market Structure
One PLUS One Equals Competition
European Equity Market Structure: Liquidity, Trust and Competition
WEB Event -European Equity Market Structure
Europe: The Shape of Things to Come
European Equity Exchanges Will Bite Back in 2009: Blink and You May Miss It
The Human Side of an Algorithm
Clearing in European Equities:Competition and Consolidation
Equity Dark Pools in Europe – Is the FSA Looking in the Right Direction?
European Equity Trading 2009: Counterparties, Capital and Control
European Equity Trading 2009 Web Event
The Problem with Exchanges Giving their Members Dark Looks
Trading in the Dark in Europe: Choice and Complexity on the Cusp of Change
Post-Trade Data: Still a Risk in the European Marketplace
XIM Signals the Emergence of a Vertically-Integrated, Pan-European Exchange
Co-location in Europe: How Do You Know Where You Need to Be?
Effective Spreads in European Equities: A TABB Group Pinpoint
Post-MiFID Market Surveillance: New Obligations and Opportunities
European Equity Derivatives – Preliminary Findings
Market Abuse is on the rise in Europe – spoof or real?
European Derivatives 2010: The Buy-Side Perspective on Equity Options, Futures and Swaps
European Derivatives Webinar
Decisions in the Dark: Aligning Results with Expectations in European Equities
The Winds of Change: A Look at the Global Landscape
Competition in European Equity Derivatives: How Likely Is It?
The Sequel to the Tale of the Trailing Stop
What’s In It For the Buy Side?
The Tale of a Trailing Stop Loss Order That Didn’t
PAVE – a Spanish MTF in the making
No Time to Lose: Change is Coming in the Nordic Markets
UK Election Results: Brussels May Be a Winner
Trading US stocks in Europe - why this will work
Achieving Effective Pan-European Governance
European Equity Exchanges in 2010: Competition is Shifting Gears
Getco plans dark expansion in Europe
EET 2010 Broker Slides - Goldman Draft
EET 2010 Broker Slides - Nomura Draft
European Equity Trading 2010: Manoeuvring in the Markets
Governance, Alignment: The Keys to Single Market Act Success
WEB Event - European Equity Trading 2010
The Deutsche Börse Says Clearing, Thinks Execution
All Change in Europe – But Where Exactly Are We Headed?
Europe 2011 –-Regulation, Consolidation and a New Dynamic
Breaking Down the UK Equity Market: Executable Liquidity, Dark Trading, High Frequency and Swaps
Breaking Down the UK Equity Market - LSE Copy
ESMA - The Future Power Behind the Proposals
The Whole and the Sum of the Parts
At Last a Strategy at the LSE: Merge with Canada's TMX
What Does an Exchange and Fertilizer Have in Common?
MiFid II Surveillance Requirements: Brobdingnagian
Dynamic Surveillance: Detection, Prevention, and Deterrence
Questions Need To Be Asked After the Latest LSE Outage
4,200 in 60 Days: MiFID Review Public Comments
Sold! Amex Building for $65 Million. Will the Hustle & Bustle Ever Return?
Commentaries on MiFID II: Proposals that will Shift the Balance of Power
"Barbarians of Wealth": History book or investment tome?
Quis custodiet ipsos custodes?
The Market-Access Rule: Blueprint for the New Regime
OMS EMS 2011: Appraising the Value Proposition of the EMS
Is It OK for a Trading Venue to Fail?
US Equity Trading 2011/12: Coverage Under Fire
Europe’s Financial Transaction Tax: Viable Solution or Hubris?
Breaking Taboo: Issuers Paying Market Makers
US Hedge Fund Equity Trading 2012: Disparate and Desperate
Data Agility: Turning a Liability into an Asset
Wall Street Is Losing Its Cool
IPO Survey: Industry Barometer
Extracting Value from Data – It Ain’t What You Do, It’s the Way You Do It
Follow-on Offerings: The New Face of Natural Liquidity
Inverted Pricing in a Dark Pool
It’s Time to Take the Circle Out of the Round
US Institutional Equity Trading 2012/13: The Paradox of a New Paradigm
People Power (No, Not the Election)
Dark Execution: Just One Piece of the Market Structure Debate
It’s Time to Shake Up the Old Lady
Tuesday Is Day One of the Inevitable Dark Debate
Changing the Equity Market by Fixing Broken Windows
BATS’s Pricing Errors Fuel Complexity Debate
US and European Buy-Side Equity Trading: An Aggregate View
US and European Equity Markets: The Shifting Sphere of Influence
Lighting the Pilot at the SEC Today
Canadian Equities Market: 2013 State of the Industry
Canada Seeks to Set the Market Structure Standard
Alpha in the Analytics: Optimizing Algorithmic Strategies
Targeting Alpha With Analytics and Algorithmic Optimization
From Sponsored Access to Sponsored Crime: The Shifting Surveillance Spotlight
Capital Markets Surveillance 2014: From Defence to Opportunity
  About  |  Services |  Research  |  Consulting  |  Commentary  | Press  |  Contact © TABB Group,  Inc.  |   info@tabbgroup.com  |  +1.646.722.7800  
 Powered by  Copyright © 2015 iWrapper, LLC. All Rights Reserved.