Imperfect Knowledge: International Perspectives on Transaction Cost Analysis 
Author:  Adam Sussman 
Date:   3/11/2008 
Price: US $ 8,000.00 

Imperfect Knowledge:
International Perspectives on
Transaction Cost Analysis

Executive Summary

Across the US and Europe, TCA is closing in on ubiquity: its usage is widespread because the desire to measure performance cuts across nearly all trading styles, investment 

strategies, geographies and even asset classes. It does not matter if you are a trillion-dollar quantitative mega-manager or a classic bottom-up stock-picker with $50 billion in assets.Both are looking at post-trade TCA. Of course, just because our PCs both have Microsoft Word does not mean that we use them in the same way. The question today is not whether TCA is on the desk, but how it impacts trading.

The magnification of transaction costs is intensifying in the equity markets as firms apply the analytics more broadly. Fundamental firms are incorporating broker-focused TCA into calculating the value of each sell-side relationship. A few firms take a more introspective approach. It is the buy-side trader that is scrutinized, and compensated accordingly. Quantitative managers are deeply embedding homegrown market impact estimates into their black box trading modules.

However, the limits—or benefits—of TCA have become clearer over the last few months. The surge in volatility has humbled much of the market, and TCA is no different. Cost attribution is more complex when prices break through probability ranges. It seems that there are more costs that are beyond the control of the trader. There are times when the diagnosis does not come with a prescription.

Regulation and transparency are the keys to opening up the possibility of more precise execution measurement. There is a symbiotic relationship between these two forces. The small number of European traders still free from the impact of TCA is dwindling, as MiFID (Markets in Financial Instruments Directive) —with its more stringent definition of best execution—exerts its influence. By 2009, 85% of European traditional asset managers will be looking at TCA, up from 70% today. At the same time, as usage spikes, there is hope that European TCA will become more accurate, as reporting requirements force more trade information into the public domain (though trade reporting has become more complex for now). 

Other asset classes are being overcome by the will to measure trading costs. As pension plans and traditional asset managers pile into alternative asset classes, innovators and aggregators are busy cooking up relevant benchmarks for listed derivatives, FX and more.

Brokers are playing a critical role in this development. Bulge-bracket brokers have been busy in the last two years developing options and FX algorithms. TCA for these products will follow as a way to demonstrate execution. The absence of existing benchmarks creates the possibilities of defining execution quality. The use of these benchmarks will in turn change behavior. Brokers who made their mark in electronic trading and TCA in equities are getting into the game, buying up names in other asset classes with a view to expanding their franchise.

The TABB Group study on Imperfect Knowledge:
International Perspectives on Transaction Cost Analysis

This report focuses on how the buy side views post-trade and pre-trade TCA, including how frequently these data are reviewed; the different benchmarks against which traders are measured and how they impact their compensation; and the impact of TCA on portfolio management. We also look at how usage patterns differ in the US compared to various parts of Europe, as well as the viability of TCA in the FX market and in other asset classes.

Among equity traders, we spoke to 137 buy-side traders, with a slight edge to US equity traders. Traders only addressed the primary market(s) in which they trade. It is much more likely that a European trader is looking at TCA across multiple markets, whereas US traders are focused solely on their domestic market. In addition, data has been collected from 27 US FX traders. 


Related Reports 
From Best Ex to Coaching:The Future of Transaction Cost Research
Transaction Cost Analysis: The New Black
TCA in the Listed Options Market
More from This Author 
Outlook on Algorithms: New Developments in Automated Trading
Managing Risk in Real-time Markets
Institutional Equity Trading 2005
From Best Ex to Coaching:The Future of Transaction Cost Research
Trading Under a Microscope: The Buy-Side Perspective on Transaction Cost Research
Hedge Funds 2006: The Quest For Alpha in a Competitive World
Hedge Funds 2006: The Quest for Alpha in a Competitive World
US Hedge Funds Spread Assets Globally
Institutional Equity Trading 2006: Return on Relationship
A Bigger Piece of a Shrinking Pie
The Right Connections
Going Public : Hedge Funds Dodge Rule 509
How to Bid for a Market
The Short Happy Life of Hedge Fund Registration
So Far, Yet So Close: Hedge Funds and Mutual Funds
TCR: Value and Efficiency
Who’s Afraid of the Big Bad… Algorithm?
PERSPECTIVE - SEC: Short, Happy Life of HF Registration
How to Bid for a Market
European Institutional Equity Trading 2007: The Buy-Side Perspective
No Home Court Advantage
TABB Forum PPT - European Equity Trading 2007
2nd Place is Last Place
Volatility and Electronic Trading
Modular Algorithms: The Growing Choice of Buy-Side Execution Strategies
The European buy-side trader: A profile for tomorrow
Undefined Benefit: How the Government Hurts the Average Investor
Performance Anxiety: A Buy-Side Study on Benchmarks and the Investment Process
Searching for the Sell Side: An Added Value to High-Touch Trading
The Universe is Expanding
Equity Swaps and OTC Options 2008: The Buy-Side Perspective
Lost in Translation: Basket Trading in a Single-Stock Market Structure
BNY Global Transition Management webcast
The Value of a Relationship
OTC Equity Derivatives: Webcast Slides
A Clear View on Risk
Pan-Asia Electronic Trading Slides
The (Hidden) ETF Market Structure
The Enterprise Spreadsheet: Pushing Toward Transparency
LSE_Derivatives Data Slides
The Uptick Rule: The Industry Perspective
CNBC TV: Adam Sussman on SEC Uptick Rule
Risk Analysis on the Fly: Fast Markets, Complex Portfolios
Equity Risk Models: The Evolution of Predictions
Contracts for Differences: An OTC-to-Exchange Fable
Spreadsheets and Capital Markets
The Investment Assembly Line: Alpha Discovery and the Illusion of Automation
PPT_HFT Methodolody
US Equity High Frequency Trading: Strategies, Sizing and Market Structure
High Frequency Trading Industry Barometer_Participant Copy
US Prime Brokerage 2009: The Hedge Fund Perspective
Demonizing the Dark
TABB Group - Exploring the Dark Ages Web Event Slides
US Senate Committee Hearing on Dark Pools, Flash Orders, High Frequency Trading, and Other Market Structure Issues
(Hedge) Fund Administration: Selection Criteria for a New Market Reality
The Buy Side Perspective on Risk: Frequency, Aggregation and Process
Chicago High Frequency Trading Slide Deck
US Treasury Market Structure
US Treasury Market Structure
US Treasury Market Structure
On-The-Run Treasury Notes: The Benefits of a Tiered Market Structure
Supreme Court Rules in Favor of Your Retirement
Russian Electronic Trading: Alpha in the Tundra
May 6th and Market Structure Reform: Industry Barometer
US Equity Trading 2010: Low Touch Trends
Equity Volumes Are Going Nowhere Fast
Hot Topics: Institutional Equity Trading
CFTC-SEC June 22 Panel on Cross-Asset Circuit Breakers
Undisplayed Liquidity: SEC June 6 Roundtable Panel 3
High Speed Markets and Long Term Investors: SEC Roundtable Panel 2
Highlights: SEC June 2 Roundtable Panel 1 - Market Structure and Price Volatility
Reinventing the Relationship: Institutional Brokerage Profitability
In FINRA vs. Trillium, Score One for John Henry
The Fatalism of Financial Reform
Against media-driven meltdown fears
What Isn’t in the Flash Crash Report?
Expert Networks: Industry Barometer
How Far Should We Go?
Treasury Trading 2011: Automating the Yield Curve
Exchange M&A: Industry Barometer
When Will IBM Be a High-Frequency Trader?
Trading Russia: Access and Arbitrage
Commission Sharing Agreements: Navigating the New Market Structure
Alpha Capture: The What, Who and How Much
Index Calculation Arbitrage
Technology Is No Market Bogeyman
Global Equity Trends 2011: Volumes, Fund Flows and Related Miscellany
Checking the Health of Global Equity Markets
On Pipeline and Our Addiction to Anonymity
Trust Me, You Won’t Feel a Thing
Cheater vs. Cheetah
Automating the Yield Curve: Soundcheck
U.S. Equity Estimates: TabbFORUM vs. Sussman
US Equities: State of the Industry 2012
U.S. Equities: State of the Industry 2012
Trading Net Alpha: Last Call for the Equities Status Quo
Reinventing Capital Markets Infrastructure
Russia 3.0: Liquidity Perestroika?
Buy-side Driven View of Market Structure Slides - Getco Event Presentation Deck
Compliance in the Age of Social
Shut Down the Dark
Risk Measurement on Demand: Complexity, Volatility and Regulatory Uncertainty
US Equities Market 2012: Mid-Year Review
The Whipping Post
The Sky is Falling: US Equity Market Structure Survey Results
The Death of a SEF: The Coroner’s Report
Kill the Black Swan
Portfolio Margining for Rates: Saving on Clearing
US Interest Rate Swap Futures: Why Market Participants Would Switch
Why DC Passed Crowdfunding; Why It Will Survive Anyway
US Equities Market: 2013 State of the Industry
The Fool and the Financial Transaction Tax
Regulatory Impacts on Market Dyamics - Webinar Presentation Deck
Capital Reformation: Alternative Financing and the Fate of Intermediaries
Crowdfunding and the Capital Markets
Biggest Dark Pool Goes Silent
@falsenews @whinytraders: 140 characters moved the market. Big deal
Don’t Blame the #HashCrash
Data and Compliance: Shedding Legacy and Embracing Change
Pole Position in the New Swaps Market
Be Open, or Be Closed Down
US Hedge Fund Equity Trading 2013: Better Practices for the Age of Transparency
Hedge Funds Weigh in on Science of Alpha Capture, Coverage Model
Social Alpha: Channeling the Chatter
Listening for Alpha in Social Chatter
Canadian HFT Regulations: A Cautious Work in Progress
HFT: A Regulatory Work in Progress
Boutique Business Model under Attack: Bruised by Regulation, Crippled by Costs?
Is the Boutique Business Model a Losing Proposition?
The $2 Billion Margin Call
Securing the Shift to Managed Services: Driving Value by Minimizing Risk and Enabling Innovation
Gaining Control of Market Data: Managed Services May Finally Rein in Costs and Complexity, Unlock Innovation
Private Equity Reporting: Transforming Data into Intelligence
US Institutional Equity Trading 2014: Bellwethers of the Buy Side
Private Equity Profits from Transparency Investments
Buy Side Does the Math – Adds Quants to Bolster E-Trading
  About  |  Services |  Research  |  Consulting  |  Commentary  | Press  |  Contact © TABB Group,  Inc.  |  |  +1.646.722.7800  
 Powered by  Copyright © 2015 iWrapper, LLC. All Rights Reserved.