US Institutional Equity Trading 2010-2011: Outflows, Outrage, and Balance 
 
Author:  Matthew Simon 
Date:   12/15/2010 
Price: US $ 8,000.00 
 
 

US Institutional
Equity Trading 2010—2011:
Outflows, Outrage, and Balance

Executive Summary
US equity managers witnessed a challenging market environment in 2010 that once again impacted long term performance and reduced investor confidence.  Focused attention on high-frequency trading, market structure challenges, and lower fee investment alternatives all contributed to new concerns.  Looking back, it is fair to say the 2010 equity markets will be remembered unfavorably.

Specifically, 2010 will be remembered as the “Year of the Flash Crash”.  Data shows the months of May and June were the most active due to higher volatility and increased selling pressures.  Preventing another major market disruption is important to restoring confidence, but is not the only action being taken.  New investments into front office capability are being made to address markets that are more complex, increasingly fragmented, and much faster. 

A number of buy-side firms are spending more time and money on figuring out new ways to remove trading inefficiencies. They are looking for new ways to improve electronic trading capabilities and leveraging existing relationships to increase their opportunity for receiving best execution.   Although there are some that feel they have reached a point of automation saturation, the majority of the buy side will be careful about investing any additional money into equity trading desks until conditions improve or volatility picks up again.

Regulations continue to be an important issue for traders. The buy-side trader has not forgotten how Reg NMS, decimalization, Reg ATS, and 28E have forever changed their businesses. This time, they are trying to take a more proactive role in the regulatory debate. However, although the voice of the buy side is becoming louder is not necessarily unified. Data shows that there is disagreement over whether the market structure needs much fixing at all. Key items include addressing high-frequency trading and reducing market fragmentation.

In terms of electronic trading, growth has steadied for the moment.  The buy side continues to argue that most broker offerings look the same. This is reflected in the relative stability in the selection of algorithmic providers.  Today, the choice of how much business a broker receives goes beyond technology capabilities.  Instead, there is an increase value on research, service, and feedback that brokers provide.

Dark pools and alternative trading systems (ATSs) continue to increase market share.  As many buy side traders are unaware of how much volume they execute in the dark, they are interested in the differences between pools, such as how pricing models impact their trading behavior and how to execute in larger blocks.  When thinking about the reason for why to do business with a particular firm, they are looking for unique flow and specialized services.

So, as equity managers enter 2011, they are looking for better ways to trade.  This can mean reducing risks when self-directing flow, or getting more out of the relationship when dealing with sales traders.  Brokers will be expected to act as partners and execution consultants as they attempt to increase market share and differentiate their business. Technology firms will be needed to assist in building the right tools to trade with more competition and greater complexity. 

Yes, outflows have changed the mindset on the outlook of the business.  But if volatility and volumes can pick up again, which we believe they should, the opportunity for the equity markets to thrive again is ripe for opportunity.

US Institutional Equity Trading 2010: Outflows, Outrage and Balance
For this year’s buy-side trading study, TABB Group spoke with 68 head traders of US institutional equity management firms. They manage an aggregate $12.9 trillion in AUM.  The discussions covered post May 6 reactions, as well as the views of head traders with regard to current regulatory proposals.  Additionally, conversations around technology challenges, commission spending, and changes in buy-side budgets and their impact on changing commission rate structures. They also examine the continued growth of low-touch trading; trends in order allocation across high- and low-touch trading venues; trends and selection criteria in algorithmic trading; and the growing demand for transparency into electronic trading infrastructure and its impact on broker relationships, leading broker algorithm and dark pool providers.

 

 
 
Related Reports 
None.
 
More from This Author 
Hedge Funds 2006: The Quest for Alpha in a Competitive World
Liquidity Management: Pushing Automated Trading Beyond Agency Brokerage
Reg NMS: Launching the New Arms Race
Commissions by Hedge Funds VS Traditional Investment Managers
So Many Products, So Little Integration
European Institutional Equity Trading 2007: The Buy-Side Perspective
The European buy-side trader: A profile for tomorrow
Size Matters
Institutional Equity Trading in America 2007: Divining a Path to Liquidity
A Changing of the Guard on Wall Street
Institutional Equity Trading in America 2007: Divining a Path to Liquidity
2007: The Year of Volatility
Hedge Funds 2008: Perspectives on Prime Brokerage, Volatility and Expansion
Taking Refuge in Equity Volatility
Portfolio Decisions and Trading: Aligning Execution to Investment Needs
Execution Cost Management: Improving Margins, Strengthening Relationships
TDAM_Compliance and Best Ex Slide Deck
Asian Equity Trading 2009
Narrowing the Digital Divide
US Prime Brokerage 2009: The Hedge Fund Perspective
US Hedge Funds 2009: Fees, Redemptions, and Managed Accounts
Institutional Equity Trading: US, Europe, and Asia
US Hedge Fund Equity Trading 2010: Commissions, Volumes and Traders
Circuit Breakers: Preventing Another Market Meltdown
Market Improvement a Definite; Jury Still Out on HFT
Hedge Fund Equity Trading 2010 Webinar Slide Deck
Hedge Fund Registration Back in Vogue
Land of the Rising Dark Pool: Race is On for Liquidity in Asia
Asia-Pac Rebound: Bouncing Back and Deserving Attention
FPL Japan Electronic Trading Conference Slides
Equity Volumes? Expect the Worst, Hope for the Best
Microsoft Share Spike Spotlights Rapid-Fire Web-Scrapers
Yuck! U.S. Equity Market Volume Hits a 2011 Low
US Hedge Fund Equity Trading 2011: The Challenge Is the Opportunity
SIFMA Cheat Sheet: Stock Market Facts & Figures
Large Trader Passes, But Not Everyone is Happy
Traders Say Large Trader Rule Has Large Questions That Need Answers
US Futures Trading: Electronic Tools Hitting their Stride
Who's Taking Advantage of MF Global's Collapse?
US Futures Trading 2012: Buy-Side Demands in an Evolving Marketplace
CME Taking Over the World
Malaysian Derivatives Trading: Growth and Opportunities Ahead
9/11: Hope is Just Around the Corner
Latest Speech by the CFTC on Dodd-Frank – “Playing the Ball where it Lies”
US Futures Market: State of the Industry 2012
The Futurization of the Swaps Business: The Latest Mermaid Developments
US FCM Business 2012: The Listed Part of the Equation
Demystifying Futures Industry Regulation: 7 Questions Answered
Congressman Dials-Up Anti-HFT Pressure on the SEC
US Futures Market: State of the Industry 2013
At Just 6 Billion Shares a Day, Every Share Counts
Regulatory Impacts on Market Dyamics - Webinar Presentation Deck
Cross Listing: The Tension of Cooperation
New Futures Exchanges Highlight Refreshing Thoughts on Strategy
Can Exchange Cooperation Save Futures Volume?
OTC Transformation Powers Futures Growth
The Outlook for Derivatives: Futurization, FCMs, and Technology
ICE Bets Credit Futures’ Time Is Now
Energy Futures: Traders' Requirements of Tomorrow
Growing Energy Futures Market Presents Opportunities, Challenges
What the CFTC Concept Release on Automated Trading Means for Derivatives
US FCM Business 2013: Posting Margin, Posting Profits
Getting the IT Customer to Spend More
Algos in Futures Markets: Shifting into High Gear
Options on Futures: A Market Primed For Further Expansion
Futures Algorithms Are the Talk of the Town
Futures Options Markets Ready, Set, Grow
New Rules in Futures Markets: Industry Perspectives on HFT and Enforcement
Futures Regulators Not Likely to Slow HFT – for Now
US Futures Market Review: First Quarter 2014
Futures Regulators Focus on HFT, But Do They Get it?
Outlook for Derivatives 2014: A Market in Transition
 
  About  |  Services |  Research  |  Consulting  |  Commentary  | Press  |  Contact © TABB Group,  Inc.  |   info@tabbgroup.com  |  +1.646.722.7800  
 Powered by  Copyright © 2014 iWrapper, LLC. All Rights Reserved.